Monday , April 23 2018
Home / Politics / Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict

Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict

Theresa May and Jeremy CorbynImage copyright HoC

Theresa May went head-to-head with Jeremy Corbyn in the House of Commons. Here's what happened.

Voters across England go to the polls on 3 May in local elections – and this Prime Minister's Questions gave us a sneak preview of the sort of campaign they can expect. It looks like it won't be pretty.

Jeremy Corbyn kicked off by challenging Theresa May to say if the collapse of Tory-run Northamptonshire County Council was a result of Conservative "incompetence" locally or nationally.

It was one of those carefully-crafted PMQs posers that is meant to put the PM in an impossible position and had Labour MPs baying for an answer.

Mrs May simply ignored it and instead declared "Conservative councils cost you less".

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionJeremy Corbyn asks who is to blame for Tory council's woes

Mr Corbyn had another go, highlighting the boasts of Northampton's Tory leader who had once said his authority had pioneered the "easy council" model, where as many services as possible are outsourced to the private sector.

"Does the prime minister believe that the slash-and-burn model for local government is really a good one?," asked Mr Corbyn.

The PM pointed to a report by an independent inspector who had said the council's problems were not down to underfunding.

Mr Corbyn accused the government of "prioritising tax cuts for the super rich and big business" over funding for social care, libraries and bin collections.

The mention of bins allowed Mrs May to get in a swipe at a Labour-run Birmingham council's bin strike.

She then revealed what she thought was her trump card – judging from the sing-song voice she adopted as she drew her reply out – comments by Labour's shadow local government secretary Andrew Gwynne, who she claimed wanted to stop voters' ability to block large local tax rises while also backing a land value tax and a "new hotel tax".

The Labour leader said Mr Gwynne didn't think councils "should be a vehicle for privatisation". He then quoted the Tory leader of Surrey County Council, who said of council funding "the government cannot stand idly by while Rome burns".

Mrs May switched to a political attack on Labour's "hard left", reading out a list of Labour council leaders she claimed had been forced out.

This sent the Commons volume up – prompting Speaker Bercow to tell MPs to emulate the "Zen-like" calm of Ken Clarke, the father of the House.

"We all admire Zen," observed Mr Corbyn.

There were further angry exchanges about local government finance – and further attempts by the PM to needle Mr Corbyn about allegations of anti-Semitism in his party and the alleged persecution of "moderates".

Mr Corbyn threw in a quote from retail guru Mary Portas, a one-time Tory adviser, criticising the government.

But Mrs May got the final word, as she always does at PMQs, and used it to trumpet the latest unemployment figures, which she said were the best since 1975.

What else came up?

Iain Blackford highlighted links between Cambridge Analytica – the firm at the centre of a row over the alleged misuse of personal data from Facebook users to influence the US election – and senior figures in the Conservative Party.

"Can I point out that the parent company of Cambridge Analytica – Strategic Communications Laboratories – has been run by a chairman of Oxford Conservative Association," said the SNP's leader at Westminster.

He added that "links to the Conservative Party… go on and on".

Mrs May told MPs: "As far as I'm aware the government has no current contracts with Cambridge Analytica or with the SCL group."

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionBlackford: Tory links to Cambridge Analytica go "on and on"

PM quizzed over Cambridge Analytica links

It all got a bit Carry On for a moment, as Tory MP Tom Pursglove asked the PM about plastic coffee cup waste.

"Perhaps if she is around afterwards. I might be able to give one to her," he asked Mrs May, who seemed to enjoy the double entendre.

The SNP's Drew Hendry brought up the alleged sell-out of the UK fishing industry in the EU transition agreement.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionDrew Hendry says the fisheries arrangement reached with the EU will leave the UK with "no say on quotas – the worst deal imaginable"

Labour's David Crausby asked about the safety of England fans travelling to Russia for the World Cup.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionTheresa May says the Foreign Office is "carefully monitoring the situation" over English fans heading to the World Cup in Russia

The Verdicts

Here is what Daily Politics presenter Andrew Neil made of it:

And here is Laura Kuenssberg's verdict:

What the BBC's Parliamentary Correspondent Mark D'Arcy made of it:

Ho-hum. Another scrappy score draw in the Vauxhall Conference. The PM seemed surprised that Jeremy Corbyn chose to attack on council cuts – and his opening question on the woes of (Conservative controlled) Northamptonshire County Council, now effectively bankrupt and recommended for abolition, left her discomforted.

But as Mr Corbyn pivoted from Northants to Surrey and Leicestershire, Theresa May recovered herself and started citing examples of quitting Labour council leaders and Labour activists switching to her party. Maybe the fact that she had such obvious lines of retaliation available to her explained her surprise.

Perhaps Mr Corbyn's most effective moment came when he pointed to the impact of rising business rates – a subject that genuinely worries many Conservatives – but he did not press that attack very far. In many ways this was a prototypical May-Corbyn exchange – him: "cuts are bad…" Her: "Labour would be worse." Parliamentary artistry it isn't.

Perhaps the most politically interesting aspect of this session was the exchanges on fisheries, The government knows it is in a difficult position over the transitional deal it has struck with the EU. Fishing communities which hoped to see Britain pull out of the Common Fisheries Policy on Brexit Day have been disappointed – and infuriated.

Scottish Conservative MPs, many of whom would lose their seats if their fisher-folk turned against them, are deeply worried and have already expressed their disappointment. There were discouraged from doing so again, today. But the intervention from Brexiteer ex-minister Mark Francois demonstrated that it is not just constituency interest that drives backbench Tory disquiet; there are plenty of Tories who are very disappointed on ideological grounds – and are putting down markers against a longer-term compromise of fishing rights after the transition.

The PM came prepared with a carefully-worded answer on this issue, but she knows it will not go away, and that she faces a real dilemma, because the electoral cost of failure on this issue could be a reverse of those vital Tory gains in Scotland.

The SNP's Drew Hendry cashed in on Tory discomfort, but his Leader, Ian Blackford, raised the Cambridge Analytica saga, detailing the links between the company and Conservative Party figures. The PM did not enjoy that – and it may have been Mr Blackford's most effective moment at PMQs since assuming the SNP's Westminster leadership.

What pundits are saying on Twitter

Skip Twitter post by @paulwaugh

Fascinating. No10 political spksman confirms Cambridge Analytica made "an approach" to work for Tory party but that was "under a previous administration" ie Cameron. Says "thinks" approach turned down under May.

— Paul Waugh (@paulwaugh) March 21, 2018

End of Twitter post by @paulwaugh

And finally, for podcast fans…

About admin

Our goal is to help you improve your life and improve your standard of living and gain more knowledge about what to do in all cases whether Business and Investing or Arts and Entertainment or

Check Also

Carwyn Jones 'not done yet' says Jeremy Corbyn

Image caption Jeremy Corbyn praise Carwyn Jones' record in his speech to Welsh Labour conferenceThe Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has paid tribute to the First Minister Carwyn Jones, following Mr Jones' announcement yesterday that he would be standing down in the autumn. Mr Corbyn was speaking at the Welsh Labour Conference in Llandudno. He thanked Carwyn Jones for his "tireless work" for Labour in Wales, and said that he "wasn't done yet". Mr Jones said on Saturday he had seen the "darkest of times" following the death of ex-minister Carl Sargeant. Carwyn Jones and Jeremy Corbyn have not seen eye-to-eye ideologically, although the first minister has never attacked him personally. Earlier a lawyer representing Jack Sargeant said Mr Jones' decision to quit had not helped Carl Sargeant's family. The Labour leader told conference that Mr Jones had called him yesterday morning to inform him of his decision. Mr Corbyn paid tribute to the outgoing first minister..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *