Sunday , April 22 2018
Home / Politics / Good Friday Agreement played up, suggests Labour's Barry Gardiner

Good Friday Agreement played up, suggests Labour's Barry Gardiner

Barry GardinerImage copyright UK Parliament
Image caption Barry Gardiner called the Good Friday Agreement a "shibboleth" at an event in Brussels

A Labour front bencher has suggested the Irish government and Sinn Fein have "played up" concerns that Brexit could harm the Good Friday Agreement.

Shadow international trade secretary Barry Gardiner said concerns about the Irish border issue was in the Irish government's "economic interest".

Mr Gardiner's comments came to light as Northern Ireland marks the 20 years of the Good Friday Agreement.

Labour's Owen Smith said the remarks were "reckless and plain wrong".

The shadow international trade secretary made the comments at a think-tank Q&A session in Brussels last month.

In a speech at the think-tank event, posted on his website, Mr Gardiner set out Labour's official position on Brexit and a customs union.

He suggested a customs union with the EU was at least a partial solution to the problem of the Irish border.

But in an audio recording obtained by the BBC, Mr Gardiner appears to play down the risks of failing to resolve the border issue post-Brexit, and suggests both the Irish government and Sinn Fein may be exaggerating them.

"We must also recognise there are real economic reasons why people have played up the issue of the Irish border and the need to have the shibboleth of the Good Friday Agreement," he said.

Shibboleth means a long-standing custom, principle or way of speaking which identifies people as a member of a group – and in some modern uses it carries the implication of being outmoded or no longer important.

"That is because it is hugely in the Republic of Ireland's economic interest to make sure there is no tariff and no external border there."

He added the UK leaving the EU did "not mean putting in a normal border relationship when one party is no longer in the EU will bring back paramilitary activity".

Image copyright PA
Image caption The 1998 peace deal brought an end to The Troubles in Northern Ireland

And there were "very good political reasons" for playing up the issue too, he said.

"Sinn Fein – who are trusted colleagues – want to see the unification of Ireland. That is a political objective of Sinn Fein.

"But that doesn't mean a normal border will bring back paramilitary activity."

He said his remarks were "deeply unfashionable".

Reports of his remarks on Twitter over the weekend were dismissed by Mr Gardiner as "nonsense on stilts".

Writing in the Guardian in March, shadow Brexit secretary Sir Keir Starmer said Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn had made it clear that his party would seek to negotiate a new comprehensive UK-EU customs union to help avoid a hard Irish border.

Ex-shadow Northern Ireland secretary Mr Smith told the BBC: "I worked in Northern Ireland with Barry and it is remarkable that he can display so little understanding of the vital and continuing importance of the Good Friday Agreement, or of the essential need to avoid any hardening of the border in Ireland.

"Labour members will be particularly shocked, but it should concern people in every party and none that there now seems to be a substantial group of senior politicians who are prepared to sacrifice the Good Friday Agreement in order to deliver Brexit."

The 20 March event was a meeting of trade unionists and selected MEPs hosted by the Rosa Luxemburg Stifung – the think tank of Die Linke, the party to the left of Germany's SDP.

A response has been sought from Mr Gardiner, and Labour did not want to comment.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionThe Good Friday Agreement: A brief guide

A number of events will take place in Northern Ireland later to mark the anniversary of the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, including a conference at Queen's University in Belfast.

Former US Senator George Mitchell, who chaired the negotiations, will join President Clinton, along with Jonathan Powell – an adviser to then prime minister Tony Blair at the time of the peace agreement – and former taoiseach (Irish prime minister) Bertie Ahern.

Lord Trimble and Seamus Mallon – the former first and deputy first leaders of the Northern Ireland Assembly – will also attend.

Later, Mr Clinton and Mr Mitchell will both receive the freedom of Belfast in a special ceremony at the Ulster Hall.

About admin

Our goal is to help you improve your life and improve your standard of living and gain more knowledge about what to do in all cases whether Business and Investing or Arts and Entertainment or

Check Also

Delayed Brexit immigration plans 'due in months'

Image copyright PADelayed proposals for Britain's post-Brexit immigration policy will be published "in the coming months", Downing Street has said. The immigration bill would establish new rules for EU migrants to the UK after free movement ends. An official policy document had been expected last autumn and the Times reports a "cabinet row" over delays. The PM's spokesman said ministers were "confident" the new system would be ready "for when we leave the EU". The immigration bill was in last year's Queen's Speech - it would enable the government to end the free movement of EU nationals into the UK but ministers said it would allow the country to attract "the brightest and the best". Last October, then immigration minister Brandon Lewis said a White Paper would be published in autumn 2017 with the bill being brought forward "in the New Year". In February, the home affairs committee noted there was still "considerable uncertainty about when the White Paper will..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *